Office Birthdays

We have a couple birthdays coming up. Shortly after I got here, I organized a calendar where we will celebrate each person's birthday by bringing in dessert items of their choice. Today, I checked with the people whose birthdays are next week, to see what they would like. One replied with a simple request. I said it was okay to be all selfish and request something specific that they would like, even if it might not be well received by others. They said that they didn't like a big thing being made of their birthday. To which I replied: "I love people. Birthdays celebrate people. You'll just have to suck it up and enjoy my enthusiasm. :)"